Debating New Watch for 2021 // DW5600 or A168

Gear Review

Choosing My Next Watch: Casio G-Shock DW-5600 vs. Casio A168

Comparing durability, style, and the joy of a low-cost horological hunt

~20

Slot Capacity

11

Existing Watches

$20–$48

Price Point

2

New Acquisitions

Table of Contents

• ①Evaluating the Contenders
• ②The Decision-Making Process
• ③Conclusion

Section I

Evaluating the Contenders

In 2021, I found myself considering a new addition to my collection. Following the 2020 purchase of my Victorinox INOX and the unfortunate demise of my Apple Series 2, I had a gap to fill. I narrowed my search down to two legendary, affordable options:

 

• →Casio G-Shock DW-5600 — The quintessential "beater" watch known for its rugged, utilitarian design.
• →Casio A168 — A classic, chrome-finished digital watch with a distinct retro aesthetic.

Details Matter

My existing G-Shock collection has always been a staple, but no single piece is perfect. My GLX-5600 is a striking red, my DW-6900 feels a bit too bulky for daily wear, and the G9000 features a negative display that can be difficult to read. I needed something reliable and versatile.

Pros and Cons

One major advantage of these watches is their accessibility. With prices typically ranging between $20 and $40, they represent a low-risk investment.

Tip: When you're hovering between two affordable options, consider the "tank of gas" rule—if the item costs less than a week’s groceries or a tank of fuel, the barrier to entry is low enough to justify the experiment.

Feature	Casio DW-5600	Casio A168
Durability	High (Indestructible)	Moderate
Water Resistance	Excellent	Limited
Aesthetic	Rugged / Sporty	Retro / Chrome

Section II

The Decision-Making Process

I believe in taking time to reflect on purchases. It’s not just about the item; it’s about the hunt and the analysis.

Update: Hands-On Experience

After spotting the A168 at Walmart, I realized that while the chrome look is sharp, it wouldn't suit my active lifestyle. I frequently swim, and the A168 lacks the water resistance I require. This led to a "mod" epiphany: I could potentially upgrade the look of my red GLX-5600 with metal parts to capture the A168's aesthetic without sacrificing G-Shock toughness.

Market Trends & Acquisition

• →Supply Chain Hurdles — By July 2021, entry-level DW models became harder to find, with Amazon prices for the DW-6900 jumping from $40 to nearly $80.
• →The Final Call — On July 5, 2021, I secured the DW-5600 for roughly $48.
• →The Unexpected Addition — By late August 2021, I found the A168WA at a price too good to pass up, ultimately bringing both into my collection.

Note: Currently, I have room for 20 watches and currently own 11. Adding these two was a guilt-free expansion of my hobby.

Section III

Conclusion

The affordability of these pieces meant I didn't have to choose just one. After a few weeks of rotating both, I have enjoyed the unique utility of each. I have since started culling other pieces from my collection to make room for these icons. Sometimes the best way to understand your personal style is to simply live with the watches on your wrist.

   

A collection is never truly finished—it just evolves.